Circular 24/2019/TT-BYT: which flavourings Vietnam permits in food
Circular 24/2019/TT-BYT is the Ministry of Health circular on the management and use of food additives in Vietnam, and it treats flavourings (hương liệu) as part of the food additive group. From 9 November 2023, Article 5(4) of Circular 24/2019/TT-BYT, as amended by Circular 17/2023/TT-BYT, provides that flavourings used in food are those on any one of three lists: flavourings evaluated by JECFA as safe at estimated intakes or at the acceptable daily intake, flavourings recognised as GRAS by FEMA, and the European Union's flavourings for use in food.
VKA Editorial | | 9 min read
Đọc bằng tiếng Việt
What is Circular 24/2019/TT-BYT and which text does this article use?
The Minister of Health issued Circular 24/2019/TT-BYT on 30 August 2019, and it took effect on 16 October 2019 S2. It applies to organisations and individuals that produce, trade or import food and food additives for circulation in Vietnam S2.
This article relies on consolidated text 09/VBHN-BYT of 6 September 2024, which incorporates the amendments made by Circular 17/2023/TT-BYT from 9 November 2023 and the repeal of Article 13 by Circular 08/2024/TT-BYT from 24 May 2024 S2. The circular's current validity status can be checked on vbpl.vn, the national legal documents database, or confirmed with the Vietnam Food Administration.
The circular was issued on the basis of Decree 15/2018/ND-CP S2. Resolution 15/2026/NQ-CP keeps Decree 15/2018 and the documents that detail and guide it in effect while Decree 46/2026/ND-CP is suspended S4.
Which flavourings are permitted under Circular 24/2019?
Article 3(3) defines a flavouring as a substance, within the food additive group, added to food to impart, modify or enhance its flavour S2. It covers flavouring substances, natural flavouring complexes, thermal process flavourings, smoke flavourings and mixtures of them, and excludes substances that only make food sweet, sour or salty, such as sugar, vinegar or table salt, as well as flavour enhancers classified as food additives under CAC/GL 36-1989 S2.
The operative rule is Article 5(4), as replaced by Article 1(2) of Circular 17/2023 S1:
"Hương liệu dùng trong thực phẩm bao gồm các hương liệu thuộc một trong các danh mục sau: a) Hương liệu đã được JECFA đánh giá, xác định an toàn ở các lượng ăn vào dự kiến hoặc lượng ăn vào hàng ngày chấp nhận được (ADI); b) Hương liệu được công nhận an toàn (GRAS) ban hành bởi Hiệp hội các nhà sản xuất hương và chất chiết xuất của Hoa Kỳ (FEMA); c) Hương liệu dùng trong thực phẩm của Liên minh châu Âu ban hành bởi Nghị viện và Hội đồng Liên minh châu Âu." S1
In English: flavourings used in food comprise flavourings in any one of the following lists: (a) flavourings evaluated by JECFA and determined to be safe at estimated intakes or at the acceptable daily intake (ADI); (b) flavourings recognised as safe (GRAS) issued by the Flavor and Extract Manufacturers Association of the United States (FEMA); (c) flavourings for use in food of the European Union issued by the European Parliament and Council S1.
The test is membership of one list, not all three S1. Article 17(2)(a) gives the Vietnam Food Administration the duty to guide how to look up the JECFA, FEMA and EU flavouring lists or databases on its website, vfa.gov.vn S1.
What did Circular 17/2023/TT-BYT change?
The 2019 text of Article 5(4) named one basis only: flavourings evaluated by JECFA as safe at estimated intakes or at the ADI S3. It added that these flavourings had to meet technical requirements for identity and purity and comply with TCVN 6417:2010 and the circular S3. The 2023 replacement keeps the JECFA limb, adds the FEMA GRAS and EU limbs, and does not repeat that second sentence S1.
Two requirements still stand. Article 3(3) still refers to item 3.5 of TCVN 6417:2010 for the non-flavouring food ingredients a flavouring may contain S2. Article 7(3) still requires food additives to meet technical and food safety requirements under: a national technical regulation, or the provisions of a legal instrument issued by a competent state authority where there is no national technical regulation; a national standard where the provisions in point (a) do not exist; CAC or JECFA standards, regional standards or foreign standards where the provisions in points (a) and (b) do not exist; the manufacturer's standard where the provisions in points (a), (b) and (c) do not exist S2.
Where is the list of permitted food additives?
The general additive lists sit in the annexes: Annex 1 is the list of additives permitted in food, Annexes 2A and 2B set maximum use levels, and Annex 3 lists additives and foods used under good manufacturing practice S2. Under Article 5(5), Annexes 2A and 3 are updated against Tables 1 and 3 of the latest Codex General Standard for Food Additives, and an additive not provided for in those annexes but covered by a Codex food product standard may be used as that standard provides S2. Where a maximum use level under Article 5(5) differs from Annex 2B, Article 5(6) gives precedence to Article 5(5) S2. Flavourings are dealt with separately, by reference to the three lists in Article 5(4) S1.
How does the circular relate to self-declaration under Decree 15/2018?
Article 11(1) of the circular requires food additives to be self-declared before they are placed on the market, with the exceptions in Article 11(2) and in Article 4(2) of Decree 15/2018 S2. Article 4(2) of Decree 15/2018 exempts products and raw materials produced or imported solely to produce or process export goods, or for an organisation's or individual's internal production, and not consumed on the domestic market S5. Article 11(2) of the circular requires the product declaration for a mixed additive with a new use, or for an additive that is not in the permitted list or not used in the foods the circular provides for, to be registered with the Vietnam Food Administration, Ministry of Health, before use or placement on the market S2. The dossier and steps are a separate topic; the main points of Decree 15/2018 are summarised on our Vietnam flavouring regulations reference. The imported case is covered in our guide to self-declaring an imported flavouring. Confirm with the receiving authority which route applies to your product.
What can a buyer ask a flavouring supplier for?
A buyer can ask for documents that make it possible to check the flavouring against the circular. This is a practical checklist, not a dossier prescribed by the clauses cited here; confirm with the competent authority which documents apply to the particular product.
- Documentation identifying the applicable Article 5(4) list and the basis for matching the flavouring to that list S1.
- The product specification, stating the technical regulation, legal provision or standard it follows under Article 7(3) S2.
- A certificate of analysis for the lot supplied.
- A composition statement identifying the non-flavouring ingredients, their levels, and INS numbers for additives that have them. Article 9(1) requires an additive carried into a food from its raw materials or ingredients to be permitted in those materials or ingredients and within their maximum level, and point (c) requires the quantity carried into the food not to exceed the maximum level in those materials or ingredients under the production process and technology S2. Article 9(4) provides that a carried-over additive with no function in the final product need not be listed in that food's composition; other relevant labelling provisions must also be considered S2.
- If you make formula products for infants and young children, formula for special medical purposes for infants (category 13.1), or complementary foods for infants and young children (category 13.2), confirmation that each carried-over additive is specifically provided for in Annexes 2A, 2B or 3, because Article 9(3) otherwise does not accept carry-over in those foods S2.
Article 9(2) sets a separate route for internal production or contracted supply: an additive not permitted in a raw material or ingredient may be used in it when the raw material or ingredient is produced or imported for the business's internal production, or for importing and distributing businesses that a food manufacturer has contracted, provided the raw material or ingredient is used exclusively to produce one type of food, the additive is permitted and within its maximum level in that food, and the product declaration is registered under Article 11(2) S2. Whether Article 10, on blending food additives and on mixed food additives, applies to a particular flavouring should be confirmed with the competent authority; Article 10 does not itself establish that a flavouring containing carriers is a mixed food additive S2.
Labelling of additives follows the labelling decree S2. Article 12 of the circular names Decree 43/2017/ND-CP, which Decree 37/2026/ND-CP has repealed S6, and Article 15 of the circular applies the replacing document S2. Our guide to labelling flavourings in Vietnam covers the ingredient wording.
What is not settled, or is changing?
Article 1 of Resolution 15/2026/NQ-CP suspends Decree 46/2026/ND-CP of 26 January 2026, which details the Law on Food Safety, and Resolution 66.13/2026/NQ-CP on food product declaration and registration, until the amended Law on Food Safety and its guiding decree take effect S4. During the suspension, Decree 15/2018 and the documents that detail and guide it remain in effect S4. Dossiers filed before the resolution took effect on 6 April 2026 continue under Decree 15/2018 S4. The resolution sets no calendar date for the suspension to end S4. The National Assembly's portal reported on 14 November 2026 that the draft amended Law on Food Safety was discussed in the first phase of the second session of the 16th National Assembly, from 17 October to 13 November 2026, and was not among the three laws passed in that phase S7. Confirm the current legal position with the competent authority before relying on it.
VKA is a Singapore flavour manufacturer certified to FSSC 22000, with MUIS halal and BPJPH halal certification. For halal documentation, see our guide to halal flavour certification in Vietnam.
Frequently asked questions
Is a flavouring a food additive in Vietnam?
Yes. Article 3(3) of Circular 24/2019 defines a flavouring as a substance within the food additive group S2.
Does a flavouring have to appear on all three lists?
No. Article 5(4) says flavourings used in food comprise those in any one of the JECFA, FEMA GRAS and EU lists S1.
What if a flavouring is on none of the three lists?
The reviewed articles of Circular 24/2019/TT-BYT do not set out a procedure specific to a flavouring that is on none of the three Article 5(4) lists S2. Article 11(2) requires a food additive not in the list of food additives permitted under the circular to have its product declaration registered with the Vietnam Food Administration, Ministry of Health, before use or before being placed on the market S2. These articles do not expressly say whether a flavouring on none of the three lists falls under that rule S2. Under Article 17(3)(d), organisations and individuals proposing an addition concerning a food additive, food type, food group or use level not provided for in the circular must supply scientific documents demonstrating the product's safety for consideration S2. Article 17(3) also establishes general duties concerning food additives: on finding an additive that does not comply with the circular, production, trading and importation must cease, as applicable, and the relevant authorities must be notified; unsafe additives must be recalled and handled under applicable law S2. Ask the Vietnam Food Administration to confirm the rules for the specific flavouring.
Is Decree 46/2026 in force for food additives?
Article 1 of Resolution 15/2026/NQ-CP suspends it, together with Resolution 66.13/2026/NQ-CP, until the amended Law on Food Safety and its guiding decree take effect, and Article 2 keeps Decree 15/2018 in effect during the suspension S4. Confirm the current position with the competent authority.
References
- S1 Circular 17/2023/TT-BYT, Ministry of Health, signed text
- S2 Consolidated Circular 24/2019/TT-BYT, 09/VBHN-BYT, Ministry of Health
- S3 Circular 24/2019/TT-BYT as issued in 2019, VCCI legal documents library
- S4 Resolution 15/2026/NQ-CP, the Government, signed text
- S5 Decree 15/2018/ND-CP, Official Gazette
- S6 Decree 37/2026/ND-CP, Government legal documents portal
- S7 Results of phase 1 of the second session, 16th National Assembly, National Assembly portal